SC credibility cannot be eroded by individuals' statements, says HC

It maintained a PIL is filed for protection of public interest and ought to be used for redressal of a genuine wrong or injury caused to citizens and it cannot be publicity-oriented

Press Trust of India Mumbai
bombay high court

bombay high court

The Constitution is supreme and sacrosanct, and the apex court's credibility is sky-high and cannot be eroded or impinged by statements of individuals, the Bombay High Court observed while dismissing a public interest litigation against Union Law Minister Kiren Rijiju and Vice-President Jagdeep Dhankhar over their remarks against the judiciary. A division bench of Acting Chief Justice S V Gangapurwala and Justice Sandeep Marne had on February 9 dismissed the PIL filed by the Bombay Lawyers Association (BLA) against Rijiju and Dhankhar over their comments against the judiciary and collegium system related to appointment of Supreme Court and HC judges. A detailed order of the bench was made available on Tuesday. The HC, in its order, said every citizen, including constitutional authorities and persons holding constitutional posts, must respect and abide by the Constitution. It maintained a PIL is filed for protection of public interest and ought to be used for redressal of a genuine wrong or injury caused to citizens and it cannot be publicity-oriented. The lawyers association's PIL had sought disqualification of Rijiju and Dhankhar from their constitutional post on the ground their remarks had shaken the public faith in the SC and the Constitution. The bench, however, noted the credibility of the Supreme Court is sky-high. It (SC credibility) cannot be eroded or impinged by the statements of individuals. The Constitution of India is supreme and sacrosanct. Every citizen of India is bound by the Constitution and is expected to abide by the constitutional values, the court said in its order. The constitutional institutions are to be respected by all, including constitutional authorities and persons holding constitutional posts, the judges added. The HC took note of the statements of Rijiju and Dhankhar submitted by Additional Solicitor General Anil Singh, which said the government has never undermined the authority of the judiciary and its independence will always remain untouched, and that they respect the ideals of the Constitution. The constitutional authorities cannot be removed in the manner as suggested by the petitioner. Fair criticism of the judgment is permissible. It is no doubt, fundamental duty of every citizen to abide by the Constitution. Majesty of law has to be respected, the HC said. Law Minister Rijiju had recently said the collegium system of appointing judges to higher judiciary was "opaque and not transparent". Vice-President Dhankhar, who also serves as the Rajya Sabha Chairman, had questioned the landmark 1973 Kesavananda Bharati case verdict that gave the "basic structure" doctrine.

The doctrine stipulates that the Constitution has certain basic features that cannot be changed by Parliament. Dhankhar had said the 50-year-old verdict set a bad precedent and if any authority questions Parliament's power to amend the Constitution, it would be difficult to say we are a democratic nation.

(Only the headline and picture of this report may have been reworked by the Business Standard staff; the rest of the content is auto-generated from a syndicated feed.)

Also Read

What is a constitution bench?

Article 143: What are constitution benches; when and why are they formed

Constitution Day: How India's founding document came to make history

Shivaji an idol, says Fadnavis amid row over statements on warrior king

SGPC seeks action against those making provocative statements in Punjab

NGT forms panel on land subsidence in Jammu and Kasmir's Doda district

Bangladesh demands Bangla be adopted as UN's official language

Residents of 'unsafe' buildings in subsidence-hit Karnaprayag to be shifted

'Angel Tax' provisions in finance bill will not impact startups: DPIIT Secy

Indians spends over $1 bn every month on foreign travel: RBI data

First Published: Feb 21 2023 | 7:56 PM IST

Explore News